Gallagher's Pizza - East Green Bay

My family honestly loves pizza, and we have pizza a couple of nights a week. Tonight, we had Gallagher's. It's been about 5 years since we last had Gallagher's. We ordered two pizzas, a classic sausage pizza, 16", and an 18" classic combo, adding jalapenos and tomatoes on half. The total was 63.00 for 2 pizzas and a 12.00 tip. The kids got the sausage hand tossed, they said it was "mid" which I believe means mediocre ¯\_(ツ)_/¯. The adults got the classic combo. When I called, I asked if the thin crust was crunchy, and the gentleman said yes, of course. So we ordered the classic combo with thin crust. It was by far the soggiest pizza we have ever had. When the delivery driver, who was awesome, polite, courteous, and absolutely crazy (he was wearing shorts), delivered the pizza, our box was

We came for the lunch buffet. Food was all very good. We arrived after 1:00, and didn’t realize it ended at 1:30. Regardless, the food that was still out was very good. Variety of items: salad, soup, pizza, pasta, appetizers, and cookies. We will definitely be back, but either come earlier for the buffet, or order off the menu.

The lack of effort put into this pizza makes me never want to order from them again. If you put this little of effort into the food what does the rest of the place have to look like. On that note anyone know of a good pizza spot in town?

Food was great but did take quite awhile to come out. Damian got the buffet which had great options. Pizza was cold towards the evening. Overall pretty decent food.

I recently moved back to Wisconsin in May. When I left Illinois I left what I thought was the best pizza ever.. I could not find a place to compare until my sister-in-law Cindy took me to Gallagher's! Absolutely mouth-watering delicious and I plan on ordering another pizza today actually. Our waitress was great. It was a good experience and like I said I finally found the pizza I've been looking for!😁 YAY! THANK YOU GALLAGHER'S GREAT JOB and like Arnold said; " I'll be back"...