Sara's Artisan Gelato - Green Bay

7Feb26 Experienced Sara’s for the first time today! We’ve missed out on this incredibly delightful place!!! Now, so happy to invite anyone to come and get their own taste-explosion from the multiple flavored gelato creations they offer you to mix together!! Seriously, yes yes yes!!! We won a gift certificate and a LOVELY pull over shirt at a benefit’s raffle.. most comfy hoodie-like thick shirt I own!, though we forgot the certificate, lol, we had to come in and so thankful we did!! The two staffers were amazing and very kind. Thank you for this wonderful experience!

I like the gelato here although I think the presentation for the affogato could be greatly improved. I was served an affogato that had immediately and completely melted upon presentation. This has not been the case at any other place I have tried so maybe staff needs to be re-trained on this, or bring the espresso & gelato out separately, or simply their gelato is not made to withstand the process to make affogato.

Delicious locally made gelato with a variety of great flavors. I took my nephews (age 10 & 13) and they thought it was so cool that they could try a sample before choosing a flavour. The 13-yr old always defaults to chocolate but I got him to try Buscotf Butter and he chose that while his brother chose the bright blue Unicorn with sprinkles. Staff was very friendly and welcoming and the store was neat and clean It smelled deliciously of freshly made waffle cones. We had a nice outing and the boys are already talking about going back to try new flavors.

Absolutely amazing place. The variety of flavors are amazing. If you want a really flavorful treat, I recommend the Strawberry Lemonade Sorbet and the Lavender Vanilla Bean. They also have their flavors in pint size containers, so you can take one home with you. Layout is very nice. 100% try this place. You won't regret it!

I lived in Italy for 17 years and have tasted and reviewed thousands of different kinds of gelato. I recently had the opportunity to try Sarah’s gelato in Depere Wisconsin while visiting family in the U.S. I enjoyed all the different kinds of gelato even more than some of my favorite places from my hometown Florence Italy. However, something that blew my mind was the service. I was greeted by the cutest, nicest worker I’ve ever met, Gracie. She asked how my day was and genuinely connected with me. I ended up asking for her name for this review and I could feel her positive aura right when I opened the door and I instantly knew my day would be changed for the better. I undoubtedly recommended Sarah’s gelato to any new or existing customers not only for the gelato but for the greatest servi