Gaetano's Deli

This has to be the best deli around. Everyone is friendly and happy. They make you feel so welcomed. You can see they really love what they do. Their subs are amazing. Made fresh, on fresh bread from Arthur Avenue. I orders a sandwich platter and a caprese platter for a luncheon. It was Outstanding! Everyone raved about how good it was. They were very appreciative of this delicious food. Thank you for helping me make people smile. Food made with love makes this world a better place! ❤️

Great experience! Felt so welcomed as soon as we came in and the food is amazing. Can’t wait to come back.

I think it was the best sandwich of my life. Perfect. I got the pesto chicken but added some sopresata to it because, well, why not? Bread was incredible. Seasoning was righteous. I couldn't get online fast enough to say how amazing it was. Whoever left the single one star review on here is obviously stupid, this place should be a perfect 5 stars. 4.9 is an insult to the ownership. I wish I could move in across the street so I could eat here every day for the rest of my life. Thank you for making me this sandwich and changing my life forever.

Amazing experience! Felt right at home here. As soon as we walked in we were greeted, acknowledged and offered several samples. The quality of the food is spectacular. Well priced for the experience you will receive.

We had a big party and ordered full trays of the penne a la vodka, rolattini, sausage and peppers, chicken franchise, chicken piccata, Italian meatballs, grilled vegetables, a six foot Italian wedge and separately italian salami and prociutto from the deli section. The food was delicious! Everyone wanted leftovers to go. Even the vegetables were such a huge hit! Delicious! We changed the pick up time for the food to be hot right before the party and everyone was accommodating and the process was extremely easy. We will order again for our next party. We love their regular menu sandwiches as well.