Gabe's Pizza

12/24/2025 I ordered a pizza, From Gabe’s on Sycamore, in Kokomo. That got delivered to my house with NO CHEESE ON IT. They made the pizza, cooked the pizza, cut and boxed it, and DIDN’T REALIZE THERE WAS NO CHEESE?! Then. When I called about the issue. They had the AUDACITY to argue with me about the fact that they were CERTAIN that it did in fact have cheese on it. I brought the pizza back, and showed them. While the girls working the kitchen, snickered in my face like I was lying. 🤦‍♀️ Needless to say, they are remaking my order. Seeing as how it was IN THEIR FACE, WITH NO EFFING CHEESE ON IT! I’ve been a customer at this very location, for years. Always order the same pizza. Never had an issue. Until this staff today. They are blatantly disrespectful. 😒 Merry Christmas Gabe’s Pizza!

Food was great! Only a 4 on atmosphere because we did carry out... Im sure we will be ordering again!!

Picked up three pizzas for the family dinner the night before we left town. The pizza was delicious and everyone devoured them. We got a Meat Lovers, a Hawaiian and a pepperoni and they filled us up.

I live in Peru In. We grew up in Kokomo and love Gabes I ordered 10/1 and drove from east rural Peru to pick up lesson learned to check pizza before I leave Gabes I drive back home the order was wrong I called to let them know she did offer me to drive the 45 minute trip one way to get a new pizza I explained I lived in Peru to far to turn around and then drive back so Gabes for your loyal customers who drive from out of town check your pizzas before they leave or offer a replacement next time

Only one young lady working. No others showed up? She was working her butt off. Our pizza was fabulous not burned this time. Not greasy. Just perfect. Again we felt so sorry for this over worked young lady. To top it off the AC was broken.