Four Brothers Pizza Inn

Four Brothers is our favorite pizza spot in Pleasant Valley. We’re the loyal customers for the last three years and I can promise you’ll like this place. The pizza is really good and their greek salad with special dressing is just perfect. The staff is always nice and the manager is always there. The place is well maintained and everything is in order and looks modern and pretty. I’m glad we have such a nice place nearby. P.S. after the renovation the toilets are missing some shelves or hooks for purses and paper towels.

We stumbled upon this restaurant on our way home from NYC. It felt like it was out of a Hallmark movie. It was clean, nicely decorated with a great atmosphere. The food was delicious and the customer service was great! The waitress was very attentive and friendly. Great experience overall and exactly what we needed to fuel us up for our 6+ hour trip!

They do pizza party slices, but it's the best pizza ive had since I moved to pv

Gave this place two chances. First time we went the the waitress dumped my entire salad on me while handing it to me. Waited almost 25 minutes for a new salad while they brought my husbands food out. Offered zero anything for the inconvenience. 2nd time ordered through DoorDash. Ordered a dinner Greek salad. It arrived the size of a side salad, old dry chicken and barely any veggies!!! Literally ONE olive. I’m done, no wonder this place is always empty.

I tried the small pepperoni 🍕 pizza for lunch. The pizza came fresh and it was hot. The pizza was wonderful. The deep dish pizza was crispy and the sauce was flavorful. I tried the gluten free pizza with the brothers toppings. I would recommend getting that brother toppings on your pizza. I definitely would recommend this place to friends and family. Come hungry