First Street Apizza

I ordered online several different pizzas for pickup on New Years Day for a party of 10 people. I received a confirmation at 11:00 am that my pies would be ready at requested time of 2:00 pm. I arrived at restaurant at 2:00 and pizzas were just coming out of oven as scheduled! There was not one guest that did not rave about the flavors of pizzas! Plenty of toppings on all and the crust was perfect!

I love this pizza place. Delicious. Friendly staff. Owners the best. Personal and friendly beyond. Deliver always on time. GET U SOME. xo

Coming from New Haven this is definitely the top of the list on where to get pizza (or food in general). The people here are very kind and understanding and have good communication. Will come again!

I don’t know what the point of this restaurant is. I just called to place an order for delivery at 8 PM. They close at 9 PM. I was told they are no longer taking delivery orders. This is the second time that I have been denied a delivery. Unacceptable. Don’t bother listing your hours if you’re not going to abide by them.

Service is awful and food is inconsistent. I called an hour before they officially close and was told they would not take my order. This is the third time this has happened. This is absolutely ridiculous. Maybe they should think about changing their hours.