Fattys

Asked what the specials were. Girl told me to just listen to the lady on the phone with another costumer because she was already telling them the specials. Asked for a pizza with NO mushrooms and a salad. What did I get?!! A pizza WITH mushrooms!!! Salad was good, I give them that. SMH!!!! Can’t be that hard to just listen is it?

I'm not sure what happened here but so disappointing! When Fattys first opened they were our favorite pizza place. Since August 2025 it went down hill quickly. We used them for our son's bday in Sept. 2025. We ordered 10 pizzas, not only did the crust change but 4 of the pizzas weren't even cut. We ordered again tonight, disgusting. Pizza wadn't even cooked, waaaay too much cheese and literally 2 pcs of pepperoni on each slice, if that. I called because we care and support local businesses. The manager said yeah, we've had similar complaints... 🤔 Umm this place needs new management and tighter training. We won't order from here again.

We tried Fatty's tonight for the first time. I ordered the Family Special with 2 large pizzas, Cheese Bread and a 2 Liter Soda. I also ordered a Large Chocolate Chip Pizza for dessert. The pizza and breadsticks were delicious! The Chocolate Chip Pizza was unfortunately not edible. It was severely overcooked. The top was burnt and the crust was hard as wreck. Don't waste the $12 on ordering one. After reading some of the other reviews it doesn't look like thay we are the only ones that have experienced this.

A nondescript, strip shopping center pizza place, but I was in town at lunchtime and decided to give it a try. A really good, fresh housemade crust and good toppings, garden salad with a great fresh ranch dressing. A good price value for the lunch special, had extra for afternoon snack or dinner.

The new desserts are a must try! The subs are top tier! Under new ownership made a huge difference, if you haven't tried in a while definitely give it a go! Great lunch and dinner specials!