Emilio's – Italian Restaurant & Pizzeria in Commack NY

My experience at Emilio’s tonight was nothing short of spectacular. From the moment we sat down, Sergio made us feel like VIP guests — warm, attentive, and genuinely passionate about the food and service. He elevated the entire night. We ordered the sangrias, the Chicken Milanese, and the Bolognese loaded with clams and mussels, and let me tell you… this was the best meal we’ve had all year. Every single dish was perfection. The sangrias were beautifully balanced and dangerously delicious, the Chicken Milanese was crisp and tender with flawless seasoning, and the Bolognese with the seafood? A masterpiece. Rich, fresh, and so thoughtfully prepared — a dish you don’t forget. The service was top-notch, the drinks were crafted with intention, and the food was on a level that rivals restauran

Took my lady out to Emilio’s and Sergio made the whole night flawless. The sangrias were unbelievable, the Chicken Milanese was perfectly crispy, and the Bolognese with clams and mussels was easily the best dish we’ve had all year. Service, drinks, food; everything was top-tier. If I could give this place a Michelin star myself, I would. Perfect spot to impress your woman and have an unforgettable night.

We ordered takeout from Emilio's and the experience is just as good as dining-in. We had a chicken parm dinner and a chicken francese dinner. They were both outrageous. The flavor and the amount you get is unbelievable. Looking forward to dining-in soon as well.

Hit or miss here. Usually too busy for me hence I will not frequent this establishment. Food is almost always good although on more than one occasion I have received cold dishes. My guests always enjoyed their meals though. Careless waiters but probably because they are too busy. The landlord of the property is a colleague of one of my clients and clearly stated that the owner is in and out of jail. I don’t believe it but I must say that this comment stuck. Food is good. Too busy though which in itself says good things as far as freshness. Mid day is my recommendation for comfort and service.

Great Place! Great food! Desert and espresso as great. Love the cheesecake And love the Italian atmosphere and music! My family enjoyed Mother’s Day brunch! Thank you!