Elm Street Bakery

Very nice place to eat. Great food selections for meals, desserts and snacks. Friendly staff and great atmosphere. Delicious pizza cooked in a wood fire bakers oven. The Margherita was delicious, chunkier sauce, dough made with All purpose flour so it has more of a bready flavor, and fresh sweet basil. A bit difficult to find parking, but thats due to how busy they are and the snow.

I’ve gone to Elm Street Bakery twice now, brought my partner with me the second time and have told no less than 15 people that they need to stop in if they’re in the area. I feel like I’m walking into a movie set when I come here. It’s just so quaint and lovely. And in the fall, it’s simply one of the best ways to spend a chilly morning. You’ll have excellent food from the kitchen, items from the bakery, and coffee. They also serve alcohol and lunch items but I haven’t tried them yet. Service is quick and friendly. Truly one of my new favorite places and well worth the 20 minute drive from Buffalo. Stay a while longer and stop at the other cute shops in East Aurora, including Second Nature right next door.

The breakfast sandwich was good but I was not expecting it to be pre-made and cold. The hot tea was nice and high quality but it's always better if they give you a little plate to put your tea bag on for once it's done steeping. Otherwise, kind staff, bustling atmosphere, and good variety of items.

Really cute place with a nice menu- we loved the wood fired pizza and the French onion soup. Got some awesome sourdough bread and s as gingerbread molasses cookie. Decent prices.

Elm Street Bakery is an absolute gem. The food is outstanding — fresh, flavorful, and made with real care. The atmosphere is just as impressive: warm, cozy, and incredibly inviting. It’s the kind of place that makes you feel embraced the moment you walk in, like a comforting warm hug on a cold day. It truly deserves a visit. Highly recommended!