Einstein Bros. Bagels

We are so glad Einstein Bros. Bagels opened here in Fleming Island! Connor served us today and made us feel so welcome. After seeing some mixed reviews, I wasn’t sure what to expect, but we were pleasantly surprised. We arrived about 30 minutes before closing (they do close earlier than some spots, so keep that in mind if you’re planning a later visit). Every employee we encountered was kind and friendly. We even saw guests arrive after us and they received the same warm service, which tells me the positive experience wasn’t just a fluke. I’m chalking up the negative reviews I read before as just a bad egg or two. My husband ordered the jalapeño cheddar brisket bagel with eggs, he said it was absolutely delicious and rated it about a 2/5 on the spicy scale. I had the six cheese bagel with

i’ve been going to Einstein‘s for many years across different states and I have to say this was hands-down possibly the best experience I’ve ever had at any Einstein. Ashley, who happens to be one of the managers is the one who helped me with my order. What can I say, she is absolutely amazing with her Customer Service. The quality and taste of my food was incredible and the timing with which they made it was also very quick. The store looks phenomenal and the staff all seem to be really really nice. Connor happens to be another. Manager is the one who made my coffee and I’m not exaggerating when I say that it was one of the best coffee's of Einstein. Plus he really went over and above with his Customer service too. If I could give this place 6 stars I would.

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ Even though the bagels I ordered weren’t available when I arrived, I completely understand that life happens and some things are simply out of our control — including running out of bagels. What truly mattered was how Erica and Brian at the Fleming Island Einstein Bagels handled it. They went above and beyond to meet my expectations and made sure I still left as a very satisfied customer. Their professionalism, kindness, and problem-solving mindset turned the situation into a great experience. Customer service like this deserves recognition. Thank you both — I’ll definitely be back!

I was excited to visit this location since the last one I went to often was when I lived in Georgia. I was greatly disappointed in what I brought home. I already spent too much time waiting for my food as all the other patrons had their food and things had slowed down. I’m not sure if I’ll be back.

This bagel shop is really good. The bagels are fresh and the combination of ingredients is unique. The lunch is nice also. I really liked the turkey and cheddar bagel. The manager said something about if you join the rewards do you can get free coffee. I wasn’t paying attention too closely because my food had just arrived and I was distracted by the quality of the sandwich. Overall a really nice little bagel shop.