Eddie D's

Old school thin crust pizza made with love. Mr. D. makes an amazing pizza and garlic knots. My husband and I had a conversation with him while waiting for our pizza and knots to get done. 40+years this family has been here. I love me a mom and pop shop!

Visited this pizza shop on my way to the airport and it was such a lovely experience. The pizza was great, and the owner is so friendly! He offered my partner and I a sample slice so we could try the food first. We got the lunch specials which were only $6 for two slices and a soda. Wonderful hospitality, and there's a lot of regulars here too. It is cash only so make sure you have some on hand.

Eddie Ds was a surprise. It has been here for years and never noticed it. When i went in I was transplanted to the 80s. The service was slow but everything is hand made i would call ahead to avoid a wait. The owner is nice and service is top notch treats everyone fantastic. The pizza! Holy moly. This was some good pizza. Crispy bottom good flavored sauce and just hit the spot. The decor can use some work and updates but dont change the food. This place is a hidden gem for pizza. Up there with Gabbys and Margarita. Try it out.

Delicious, great, classic pizza. The owner is friendly and knows all of his customers. Gave us a free slice while waiting for our pie to cook. The bottom was perfectly crispy, and the pepperoni was thick. Absolutely delicious highly recommend.

I’ve lived in New York City my whole life. From Brooklyn, to Queens and even the Bronx. I’ve tried pizza from all the 5 boroughs and non are as good as Eddies. You get a high quality slice with great service. You don’t get service like this from anywhere these days. When you go into Eddies you go back to a simple time where ingredients are fresh, conversations are warm and welcoming and the pizza is hot and delicious. Don’t sleep on this spot. It’s worth the trip and is some of the best pizza you can find in all of New York and Long Island