D'Tutanelli's Pizza-Amherst

We visited here with some family, and they have a lot of options from subs to specialty pizzas and more. We tried a variety of things, including a BLT sub, Pepperoni bombs, Flaming Kramer pizza, and Blazing Buffalo Mac n Cheese pizza. Everything was fantastic. Their pizzas were unique and full of flavor. We were the only ones dining in at the beginning, and service was great. They were very attentive, and several waitresses checked on us frequently.

Super friendly staff. Chicken Parm sandwich was perfectly cooked and delicious. I added jalapenos to mine. Meat ball appetizer was really good too!

Placed an order for a pizza for delivery was told an hour two hours later. I still have not received a pizza so if you are ordering for delivery, don’t expect to get your food in a timely fashion! Very disappointed!

Unfortunately this is the second and last time I will be ordering from here. Although the service was fast and friendly, the product was not good, made incorrectly and overpriced. I ordered a medium cheese, pepperoni and mushroom pizza and 6 garlic parmesan wings well done. First off I was charged $2.25 for mushrooms and there was not a single mushroom on the pizza. Also a $13.50 medium pizza with an additional charge of $2.25 for pepperoni seems a bit steep to me. The wings I ordered were $10.99 for 6 which is outrageous and they were awful. There was no parmesan on them and they were soggy. I ordered them well done so I expected them crisper. So at the end of the day it cost $28 for a medium pizza and 6 wings, I was charged for ingredients that were never added to the pizza and the wing

Mac'n cheese pizza has a chokehold on me, and this is the only place I go for it. That and the cheese bombs. The staff are very polite and efficient. Definitely 10/10 🩷🩷