Don's NY Pizza in Peoria

Pizza is amazing honestly. If Dave portnoy came here he would give this place a solid 7.5 to 7.9 it’s not in the 8s. But it’s definitely worthy of a try. I’ve eaten NY pizza since I was a kid all the time. This pizza really reminds me of ny pizza in a way. The taste is nostalgic. Atmosphere is eh. People are friendly here and serve you without attitude. I’ve come here so many times and I have never been let down on a regular cheese slice. Come here is you want to experience a subtle taste of what ny pizza can taste like!

I decided to try this place after hearing good things from a few people. When I called to place an order, the lady on the phone told me they require payment over the phone to confirm the order and wouldn’t take it otherwise. I mentioned that I would be coming in shortly and preferred to pay in person, but she still declined to take the order without upfront payment. While I understand policies, it was a bit inconvenient. When I arrived, however, the lady at the counter was very sweet and helpful. She took the time to help me choose the right items, which I appreciated. I ordered the Spicy Alfredo Pasta with chicken, which comes with salad and bread. The food was ready in about 15 minutes. The salad was very basic, but since it was complimentary with the dish, I have no complaints about t

We just left there and got home to find the food is horrible! The pizza was so greasy, we ordered half pepperoni and half pineapple, we got a whole pepperoni with pineapple on half. The pineapple wasn't cooked/hot. The crust cpuldnt withstand the grease. The wings are not what we ordered, and they're dry/overcooked. I ordered that Asian style wings, got some kind of Franks red hot 🥵 wings med to hot. We live up the street and we'll never go there again. Not sure how they're still in business honestly. Should have taken it all back, but they close at 9pm, so.....should have read the reviews before we went!! It was $45 for their smallest pizza and 10 wings, plus the "obligation to tip", even though im picking it up, etc it was $50! Foe 2 people. What a Rip off. I will say though, the place w

We came here for dinner after a long drive back and we're not feeling cooking. There were a few people in the restaurant waiting for their orders. It was clean, so clean the mop and bucket were left in the middle of the room. It didn't take long to place our order. The mozzarella sticks came out first, they were hot and fresh, but when you bit into it there was no cheese pull and were very bland. The marinara was also very bland. The wings came out next and initially they were very dry where I went and asked for additional sauce. 1 guy was very nice, I'm guess the boss while a young man complained so the first gentleman just did it. They use franks red hot and was hoping for somethkng more housemade for the wing sauce. The pizza is super greasy and very basic.we appreciate them accommodati

We just happened to drive by and see Dons and stopped in. It was fantastic, the food was delicious and quick. The manager Antonio was so welcoming and helpful. My son dropped his ketchup and antonio cleaned it for us with a smile. The overall experience was so good, we will be back again! Antonio and the staff made the experience a 10/10