Dominick's Italian-American Deli

They’re known for their chicken tenders, so of course that’s what we ordered and they totally live up to the hype. We couldn’t stop snacking on them. They’re so addictive, and honestly feel like eating fries… except they’re chicken, so it’s basically guilt-free protein. The honey mustard deserves its own shoutout it’s not too thick, tangy, and sweet. It sticks perfectly to the chicken without feeling too heavy, and the flavor balance makes it one of the best honey mustards I’ve had. We also got the Bella Calabria sandwich, which was fully loaded and packed with flavor. Generous portions, and all the ingredients are fresh (definitely something you need two hands for) Lines can get really long on weekends, so I’d recommend ordering about an hour ahead online to save time. Excited for the p

A go-to spot in New Hyde Park for top-tier deli eats. The chicken fingers are excellent, and their Italian-style sandwiches are some of the best around. I came by at 3 PM and still waited 10 minutes—always busy, and for good reason. Tried the Kevincito Special with chicken fingers, fresh mozzarella, and broccoli rabe—solid 8/10. The cole slaw was excellent. Portions are big, prices are very fair, and the quality never misses. Great service, great food—definitely worth the wait. I’ll keep coming back and recommending it.

This sandwich has fried chicken cutlets and hot Soppressata and Prosciutto with fresh Mozzarella, roasted red peppers and balsamic glaze on a semolina Hero. Truly delicious. The name of this sandwich is the Fitz & Slip. The sandwich was around $13 it cost more to get a sandwich at a place like Jersey Mike's that doesn't even come close to the quality of this sandwich.

First time going here to pick up their iconic chicken tenders for a party and aside of the food being delicious, the staff are 10/10. Seems family owned. I only had one small tray and one of the employees (maybe manager or owner) was adamant that his son carried it to my car for me. Seems like he’s raising really nice respectful young men who respect women and I LOVE it. Great place all around food and beyond

I’m from Brooklyn. Spent most of my life in Brooklyn before moving to Long Island. This deli reminds me of home. Every sandwich is perfection. Salads are fresh and delicious! Chicken fingers are a winner and different from other chicken fingers. Service is friendly and feels like home. Love this place!!