DiMare Pastry Shop

My family’s go-to cake place! The spice cake with cream cheese frosting is a sleeper hit, perfect in the fall. The strawberry with cream and vanilla cake is also a classic and I can’t forget the cookie platter and the pretty sugar cookies. You really can’t go wrong. Everyone is so nice and helpful.

I went in with my coworker today. The shop smelled delicious, is impeccably clean, and has many options. We met and spoke with Kim. She is kind, personable, and really proud of Di Mare. We had great conversation & left with several mouth-watering sweets; for our office. I've had cakes from Di Mare before and they are delicious. I feel compelled to write a review mainly because the personality and whole vibe in the shop! I highly recommend & will definitely return! Would give more than 5 stars if there was an option.

I ordered my anniversary cake from here & it was ABSOLUTELY disgusting!!! It tasted like something that would be served at a nursing home. I requested for yellow cake with a raspberry filling with butter creme frosting and ended up receiving a sponge cake with barely any filling and large amounts of whipped creme. It was very disappointing to say the least because I drove 2 hours from Middletown to pick up the cake. My husband was very sad about it because he was so excited to enjoy it. He tasted it and said that it tasted OFF and I would have been better off ordering a cake from Carvels or Cold Stone Creamery. This is the SECOND year in a row this bakery has let us down and ruined an order. Last year we ordered our anniversary cake from the Hope Street location & the baker had to refund

I had ordered a cake for my niece a week before her birthday. I was told that the baker would be able to make it as similar to the original idea. Unfortunately when I went to pick up the cake, not only was it lopsided but it also had many unfinished details. I am very disappointed to say the least because I have been purchasing cakes from here for years. This cake has shown me they are losing interest and value of their work. Do better.

I purchased a dozen assorted pastries and a dozen cookies plus 2 dessert breads and was pleasantly surprised that the total was extremely reasonable. All the items were very good