Cugini's Pizza

I’ve had pizza here before and also the other location in Middletown. Generally, good pizza. It’s not the best or go out of my way and drive for it, but compared to others, it does the trick. I ordered through Slice. Order was for pickup. More specifically, I was looking for a grandma pie and couldn’t find pics of it. So I took a risk since I like trying new places and placed an order for a grandma pie and garlic knots. They list it on their menu as “Grandma’s Pizza”. Super quick order. Of course we all know, pizza boxes kill a pizza. Once opened, it looked great. It lost its heat which sucks but I don’t fault that on the business at all. That’s the risk you take. The cheese is great. The sauce is good. Compared to other places, slightly less sweet. It was good though. I’d recommend get

Been ordering for years. Not sure what's been going on. Took over an hour for our food to get here (we literally live across the highway barrier) come to find out the girls who take your order over the phone put the wrong address for the delivery guy (he called us to verify where we lived because he was lost, proceeded to tell us the address written down by the girls, which was completely wrong) anyway, we finally get our pizza and this is what we received. A pie that looks like it was in a car wreck. Literally the cheese and toppings slid off half the pie and ended up on the box itself. The pizza dough itself was so soggy, we ended up having to cook it in our OWN oven to make it somewhat better.

2023 1st time here, and they had a great selection of pizza to choose from. I purchased the chicken and beacon slice, the chicken frances, and the onion pepper sausage slice. All were delicious. I love that they were large pieces, and the crust was awesome. 2024 We went back and had the spaghetti & meatballs, chicken scampi. Shrimp Diavolo, with penne pasta , comes with a salad, bread. My honey doesn't like parmesano, so they had to take it back, and I have to say, Tony took it back with a smile and said no problem. He was so gracious and is so friendly. Our server was Angie she was great! They have a continuing customer. The food was delicious, and Oh my, the pizza reminds me of when I grew up in NYC, LOVE IT!! 😁

Pizza is good. Nice selection of specialty pizza by the slice. Staff is friendly and professional.

Delivery is unpredictable to its local clients it can take up to hour plus for 1 pizza pie. They other own deliveries so their no visibility in the apps. This happens every-time I order after 5, before 5 it takes an hour after 5 it can take almost 2 hrs to get your pizza for a place 15 mins away. The is good it’s the operations and service that needs improvement. Test for yourself at your own risk. When they mess up they also take no accountability and offer 5% refund thanks for the $1.50 back for making us wait almost 2 hrs for dinner. First time this happen accident but second time in a month it’s a way of working thanks but no thanks.