Craft Bagel Co.

Craft Bagel Co is a good spot to Berkeley Heights. The bagels are always fresh, chewy, and full of flavor — easily some of the best in the area. The staff is friendly, and the service stays quick even during busy hours. The atmosphere is warm and inviting, though the space inside is a bit limited, still, it’s a nice spot to grab breakfast.

We made an intentional stop here from Manhattan because Craft Bagels was our favorite stand at the NYC Bagel Fest 2026! However, the bagels in the store were not good… The bagels looked plump and great but turned out to be extremely dry! We enjoyed the apple french toast special but it also seemed like it was sitting out for too long when we stopped by around 12. No place to sit. No bathroom inside.

Absolutely delightful, I will repeat for sure. One of the best bagels I’ve ever tried, the bagels are incredibly tasty, warm and well prepared, the service is lovely and kind. Great experience and it’s a must!

I must express that this bagel shop is truly exceptional. From the staff to the quality of the food, it is undoubtedly the best. There is a wonderful energy as soon as you enter. I thoroughly enjoy it! Excellent work.

Definitely the best breakfast sandwich! The bagels are a good size and very tender. The eggs, cheese and Taylor ham are plentiful and cooked well. The service is fast and the staff friendly. Definitely recommend!