Cookie Maven

Absolute best cookies I’ve ever had! Toby the owner and everyone I’ve encountered in the store are beyond nice and helpful. I did a large special order for my baby shower favors and the cookies were a HUGE hit. Everyone was asking me where they were from. So happy they moved even closer to me now!

The espresso chip cake was beyond delicious. My kids enjoyed ice cream. They support other small vendors if you need something small to go with a gift card. So happy Califon has a fun new bakery!

Nothing to say about this place but YUMMY. Small in the cut spot. Very nice owners. Sweet and kind. I had the almond horn and the chocolate chip chunk. Both extremely good. Soft but firm. Not too sweet. Just made with love.

Fantastic local bakery, with an impressive selection of gluten-free and dairy-free cookies in addition to traditional. From the traditional cookies we loved the whoopie pies, almond thumbprint with apricot jam, and the Reese's peanut butter cup-stuffed cookie (yeah, it's awesome). In the gf selection so far we've tried the peanut butter sandies and chocolate chip cookies--all delicious. We'll be back for more!

Never thought I could love something that wasn’t alive. That is until I met cookie maven. Delicious fresh and sweet rich but not overbearing pastries. Extremely kind owner who never rushes and takes time to explain everything and any question I have. Cannot recommend this place enough and will never need to bake again as long as I live in NJ with cookie maven.