Cincy Sammys

I love the idea but I probably wouldn't go out of my way to stop in here again. They had a great teacher theme for their cookies as I got a Mr Feeny. So the cookie are delicious yet slightly too rich for my daughter and me. I would still get one. The ice cream is slightly more icy than creamy for my taste. The price of $7.25 or $6.25 seems a bit steep for a scoop of ice cream and a cookie. I always like this idea but think it could be done for cheaper. I also would like a creamier ice cream. If you are in Mason, sure stop in but I chose this out of 5-5 places I was looking at and then drove out of my way hence the lack of hype. Decent with nice cookies but a little more wallet than I like.

Amazing service, homemade cookies paired with ice cream is unbeatable! This is not a chain, so come and support this amazing local business! I was not paid for this review, I am a highschool senior who fell in love with this shop.

Amazing!! They have gluten free cookies that are super delicious as well as the ice cream is super good too. Update! Came back to leave a 5 star review and realized I already did. I can’t even believe how good their gluten free cookies are and they make nearly all of their regular flavors into gf which is amazing!

What an amazing place! - The basic concept is amazing of rotating cookies and ice cream and make your own ice cream sandwiches. - They of course have other things like Stuffed Cookies (Insane) and Skillet cookies too! - We loved the atmosphere also with the board games and just the feeling of comfort. - We absolutely loved this place and feel it fits right in in downtown Mason.

First time here. We tried the peanut butter, chocolate chip and molasses tonight. The molasses was by far our favorite. We both found the peanut butter a little dry and the chocolate chip, while decadent, too much. But we look forward to trying the other ones we got tomorrow and will be back!