Cicero Country Pizza

I haven't gone to this place in over 30 years after moving away. Had to visit again since I was back in town and it's as delicious as I remember. Same recipes that I remember. Pizza, wings, and fried dough. Nostalgia was running high as I remembered frequently eating here with family that are now gone. Thank you for tradition and delicious memories.

There wasn’t a single thing right about our order — not even the time it was supposed to be ready. We waited 20 minutes past the scheduled pickup time, only to realize the food had clearly been forgotten and then rushed together last minute. The pizza was completely undercooked with barely any pepperoni, and the calzone was doughy and mostly empty. The fried cauliflower was also undercooked, and the portion size was terrible for the price. We tried to call when we noticed the issues, but the phone was constantly busy — it seemed like it was taken off the hook. So we drove the entire order back, and when we got there, the staff was rude and completely unapologetic. No accountability and no effort to make it right. Extremely disappointing experience from start to finish.

We ordered tonight after not ordering from there in a while. Everything was Perfect! The fried cauliflower can't be beat, the fried dough was amazing and I can't believe how big the calzone still is. Super delicious, friendly service and reasonable prices for delicious food. Thanks for a great meal.

Cicero Country Pizza is a standout pizza restaurant that delivers delicious, well‑crafted pies with a flavor that keeps customers coming back. The crust strikes a great balance — crisp on the outside yet tender inside — and toppings are generous and fresh, whether you choose classic pepperoni, veggie‑loaded options, or specialty pies with creative combinations.

If you have never been here, then you HAVE to go. Everything they have is great, but their house saucy wings are to DIE FOR. I’m not sure how to describe them or what is in the sauce, but it is not buffalo sauce. It is like a combination of tomato sauce with a little hint of bbq. I make a total disastrous mess of myself eating them, and I enjoy every minute of it.