Cheshire Farms Creamery

I absolutely enjoyed the sample I had of the Curly Tail Maple and i asked to have a milkshake made with it. Then I got a pint of the ice cream. It was so delicious there are pieces of bacon in it. I highly recommend if you like bacon in your ice cream.

The ice cream is really good. It is creamy but melts in your mouth without leaving a thick cream. The flavors are good but light and not overpowering. The ice cream is sweet but not as sweet as places like cold stone and Baskin Robins. Homemade treats were just okay. They didn't seem to turn quite as quickly. Bathrooms. There are two single bathroom stalls for either gender to use.

Updating my review from 3 years ago. 3 Stars as the ice cream is always good. Some may say the wait is worth it, but to others not. My husband and I got to Cheshire Creamery at 8:06pm on a Sunday evening. We left with our items to go at 8:46. There were 3 families that ordered ahead of us and 3 more that were waiting for their orders they already placed by the time we got there. Service is always consistently slow here. It may be the Creamery struggles with staffing as a lot of places are right now, however I can say from experience, service is always slow...even prior to Covid. Maybe it's a scheduling the right amount of people thing. I ordered a twist waffle cone with chocolate sprinkles. The twist initially came out with no sprinkles, so I asked and the woman who took the order didn't

Love the atmosphere and the Quiche as well. The Ice Cream and Finger Lakes Coffee and flavors are really good. Soups are back and they are really tasty. Thank you for sharing your yumminess with the local area!

Delicious ice cream and nice atmosphere. We had tree different ice cream flavor- all of them where very good. We’ll definitely come back.