Chef Justin’s Sunset Keys

Chef Justin provided my wedding guests and I with an unforgettable evening back in September 2025. The atmosphere was delightful on the outdoor patio area - we were allowed to set up some of our own decor. Our dinner was absolutely incredible (so much so that we were too busy eating and didn't take many photos of the food!). Plus, the staff were kind and accommodating for our party of about 50 people. Everyone RAVED about the food through the rest of our wedding weekend. Thank you all for a lovely night to celebrate with our loved ones. It was the perfect welcome party to kick off our weekend of celebrating. We will 100% be back and recommend to any friends and family visiting the area. Thank you!

We were SO excited to find out that Sunset Keys has reopened! The menu is full of delicious options & everything we tried was absolutely amazing. The new fried olives appetizer is so unique and tasty. If you like seafood, you HAVE to try the scallops - they are unbelievable! Pasta made in house was so fresh and amazing. The staff is so friendly and helpful! We can’t wait to come back soon!!

We had the best experience at Sunset Keys Café in Lavallette! From start to finish, everything was fantastic. The atmosphere is unbeatable—outdoor seating with a beautiful view, perfect for enjoying the sunset with friends. The food was absolutely delicious and beautifully presented. The pasta was rich and flavorful, topped with fresh Parmesan and burrata. The seafood dishes were so fresh—the shrimp was cooked perfectly and paired wonderfully with the veggies and sauce. The salads were crisp, refreshing, and generously topped, whether with shrimp, chicken, or steak. Everything tasted fresh and thoughtfully prepared. The service was friendly and attentive, making the whole evening even more enjoyable. Between the great company, amazing food, and relaxing setting, this place is truly a gem

Chef Justin’s Sunset Keys has become my favorite/go-to spot for dining around Lavallette. The menu is always exciting and the food is always amazing! The staff is friendly and attentive. The location along scenic Bay Boulevard can’t be beat! Where else can you get this sunset? We love bringing our own wine which gives us more spending room on the dinner bill. Chef Justin stopped at our table once - what a nice guy! Can’t possibly recommend Sunset Keys more highly!!

One of the best in our backyard! Views of the sunset over the bay while having dinner is just breathtaking! Plus with good food! Always delicious!