Central Pizza & Italian Restaurant

I don't like to be negative but unfortunately I am not happy with my last order and I do want to share. I ordered a large cheese and a 2 liter. 30 bucks. An hr for delivery and the pizza arrived cold. I asked for root beer and they did not have. That's fine, I asked for sprite and they delivered sprite winter cranberry edition. The pizza crust tasted just like it smelled. Old and dirty.

Stopped in for the first time & grabbed two slices of pizza. The pizza was excellent, though a bit pricey (2 slices cost a bit over $8).

I am so happy Central Pizza has reopened after calling it quits. It amazes me what the Red Lion Community did for this small business. Central has a newfound passion and it shows. With a newly refreshed dining room and so many new options to choose from like Grab and Go, Make Your Own, Catering, Desserts, and Pay it Forward, the shop has the potential to grow and to run another 40+ years.

We ordered a Sicilian pizza with pepperoni and thought it was just “okay”. The sauce is flavorful and you get a good amount for your money, but we felt as if the Sicilian was too bread heavy. While a Sicilian is supposed to have a think crust, I felt like I was eating a loaf of break more than I was eating a pizza. We may order from Central Pizza again in the future, but we’d definitely try something else. There are also other pizza places in the area that we enjoy more, so we’d probably just opt for them.

Been going here for years. Tonight ordered a Sicilian Style Pizza. 1st, the regular portioned toppings were barely there. 2nd, the bottom of the pizza was burned. 3rd, the "extra" cheese was barely a regular portion... $31.60? Really? Thankfully the 2 orders of wings were fine, but if this is the new "normal" for their pizza, then sadly we won't be going back.