Casey's

Pretty nice gas station. Super close to Arnold’s park amusement park. The staff seemed pretty friendly. The pizza was delicious. It took about 35 minutes to get a pizza but they were pretty busy. The prices are pretty fair. It is my go to gas station when I am at Arnold’s park with my family.

We tried parking at this Casey’s for the Fourth of July show and were met with an extremely rude woman who clearly had no interest in handling things respectfully. We completely understand if they don’t want people parking here — that’s their right — but the way we were yelled at was totally uncalled for. Her attitude was aggressive and unnecessary, especially when a simple, polite “Sorry, no parking here” would’ve done the job. After that experience, we have no interest in coming back.

After reading the reviews I see that a few had the same disappointing experience that I did at this store. I went at 8pm on New Year's Eve 2021, and my whole order was jacked up. I ordered 4 pizzas and 60 wings that totalled more than $84. I went back and forth about where to get pizza from and we decided on Casey's. I've never had a bad experience since I've been ordering from Casey's. I came here from Cedar Falls, Iowa to spend the holiday here and it was horrible. be going up the chain to see

The outside trash was over flowing onto the sidewalk. The women’s restroom had no toilet paper, an over flowing trash, & the sink looked like it hadn’t been cleaned in a week. The kitchen staff & front staff were yelling back & forth across the store, about killing each other. My cashier talked to a coworker the entire time helping me, as if her job was an inconvenience. AP Casey’s is just as bad as Milford’s.

One of only two gas stations in the town of Arnolds Park, with this being the older and smaller of the two. While I would say this particular Casey’s location could benefit from an update, remodel, or rebuild, it’s not bad how it is. The lot is far from cramped and they have free air for your low or flat tires. Donuts are pretty good and the gas price is competitive with other stations.