Carter & Ellie’s

We had evening craving for a cookie ice cream sandwich we ordered through door dash . I came here to say it was the most amazing cookie ice cream sandwiches we have ever had ! We look forward to having another one soon .

Enjoying the best Key Lime Pie I’ve ever had thanks to Carter and Ellie’s! What a friendly, sweet addition to Newmarket. The peanut butter cookie was divine and my family and I will certainly be back!

Absolutely loved our visit to this cozy little gem! The coffee was rich and smooth, easily some of the best I’ve had and the giant cookies were perfectly baked, gooey, and unforgettable. We also had the broccoli cheddar soup, which was perfectly creamy and comforting, and the grilled cheese was golden, melty, and just what we were craving. You gotta try the key lime pie, nothing short of amazing! A must-visit spot for anyone who loves quality treats and a warm, welcoming vibe!

Cute family run shop with the most delicious treats! Also had a sandwich they were debuting that day and it was perfect. Can't wait to try the soups!

Unreal desserts! Amazing fudge no too sweet, ice cream selection was perfect and large, and prices were great! I will be back! 10/10 experience