Carlo's Pizza Shirley

Exceptional service! A very sweet young man took my dinner order for my husband and me. Then a lovely young lady brought our dinners out to the table and she was just as kind and pleasant. The portions are huge , we could barely finish everything! It’s so nice to still find places with such friendly service. We will definitely be coming back.😊

Excellent pizza. Friendly staff. Best part, only 4 minutes from Home2Suites in Yaphank.

Best pizza I’ve had so far in LI. Been in town for a week or so and have been trying out different places.

Great pizzeria with tons of choices and a friendly staff. Yes, there are lots of teens working here but they were all helpful and polite. The food was fresh and the Sicilian slices were delicious. The cannoli filling was a little sweet for me but my family loved them. The vodka chicken sliders were also great. Red dipping sauce had a little zing to it. Fair prices and prompt service even though it was a very busy night. Will definitely come here again.

Order in person to watch and make sure your pizza is fresh. I live 5 min away. I was told 15-20 min. Got there then was told 10 more min. I asked for garlic, cheese, and red pepper considering it’s a LARGE PIE! Clearly not for 1 person. I was given 1 empty fill up container and no top. Then I had to wait and ask for the other one. Napkins?? Oh it’s right there. Considering the $30+ dollars you are spending in these times!! You have to do better in serving your customers, especially in the area you’re in. I cannot understand how I get home and the pizza is cold in just 5 min and I have to put in the oven for another 10 min to reheat. And deal with a HANGRY hubby! You know that “WHAT TOOK YOU SO LONG TONE! We are 5 min away! Guess I will have to go to another pizzeria/restaurant.