Captain D's

Captain D's used to be one of my favorite restaurants but, because we only have one in town now, in Evansville and not in Newburgh, where I live, I rarely ever get to enjoy Captain D's, anymore. I had stopped to pick up a U-Haul truck before having lunch at Captain D's in Evansville. I ordered the lobster bites and more which was lobster bites a piece of fish, french fries and hush puppies. I also ordered the butterfly fried shrimp 5 for only $1.99! Wow! I also ordered a lemonade sweet tea! Everything was made fresh for me and everything tasted amazing! I recently joined the Long John Silver's restaurant club I was disappointed with the way the food was made and the way the food tasted. Everything was super greasy and a little bit overcooked and after eating it, I felt absolute regret.

Had Feast and Fried Catfish. Catfish was pretty good. Good crispy crust. Feast was good. Everything was hot and crispy. Service was good and fast.

Fresh and Delicious. The Catfish was new to me - and it didn’t disappoint. Still some of the best okra I’ve ever had - and for the value, great food.

I eat here often and have only ever had one mishap, with forgotten sides. The service has always been good and the food mostly decent. If it isn’t, they’ve always been accommodating and willing to fix it. Tonight, however, was different. Had this been my first time eating here, you’d have lost me completely as a customer. From here on out, I’ll stick to fish, or go elsewhere. I picked up dinner for my son. I ordered a 4 piece chicken meal for $11.09, that comes with two sides. He got garlic fries and Mac and cheese. I also ordered a medium drink. When I went to pay, I was charged $17.46. Upon further inspection, I was charged an additional 99 cents for each side, even though it comes with two sides. Nowhere does it specify, that there’s an up charge for sides. I get the food home to him,

Second time getting dinner, second time being shorted. Got shorted on 4 fishies and broccoli, again. The fishies and chickies we did get were very good. Drive thru gets backed up around supper time, so plan accordingly.