Calissa Hamptons

The food was delicious. The staff was friendly. The prix fixe was very reasonably priced and served in generous portions. We were told that they have live Greek music on Sundays which we missed. Great place for great food at a reasonable price in the Hamptons. Not to be missed.

Calissa has such a cozy yet upscale vibe and the staff is always so welcoming and attentive. The Greek salad was incredibly fresh and flavorful and the steak was cooked perfectly. Everything we ordered was delicious and beautifully prepared. It’s the perfect spot for a relaxed dinner or a night out with friends!

The food and service at Calissa are unparalleled. Love their wine list, zucchini fritters, langoustine and chicken! Their Select Spritz is a favourite and Tanya made sure we had the best time and were well taken care of along with the rest of the staff at Calissa who are a delight. The warmth, hospitality, vibes, consistently great food and drinks is something we return for year after year! If you go to one restaurant in the Hamptons make sure you stop by Calissa.

Calissa is an excellent option and well-priced for the Water Mill area for superb Greek cuisine. The Winter Short Rib entree is delicious, perfectly prepared, and worth the trip if not local. The Saganaki, Calamari, Mezze Platters, sides, and all items tried were delicious and served fresh. The bartender made perfect drinks for all, and timing of the meal was perfect. Israel is a gentlemen as well. Reading some of the reviews, many seem to complain in the high season of some delays in food preparation. Sometimes you should enjoy the ambiance and know your food is prepared fresh, and we look forward to dining at Calissa year round.

Been here several times before and really enjoyed the previous staff I had met and the food. Came in the winter and enjoyed it a lot less-food was not fresh, which I get working in the restaurant business especially during cold weather. As someone who has bartended for years I always make sure to tip 20% or more always, but this time a 17% gratuity was added to my check? When I dined alone? I found it weird when I hadn’t had that happen to me before and it felt off when the server had also asked me if I had been there before. The bar top was also especially sticky considering the restaurant was basically empty. Hopefully it was a one off tn, I always enjoyed stopping by here w my dog!