Brotherhood of Thieves

Traditional lobster roll was excellent with a subtle hint of lemon in the sauce which I loved. The burrata and tomato app was also unexpectedly delicious with the balsamic pearls. The salmon nigiri was also excellent! We ate in the pub and the atmosphere was cool but a little loud and service was a little slow, still we would highly recommend to anyone traveling to Nantucket

Nantucket Mass. We sat at the upstairs bar for lunch. For drinks: Old fashioned with Basil Hayden and a Grey Lady Ale for the hubby. For lunch: I had the chicken cobb salad (no blue cheese) and the hubby had the buttermilk chicken sandwich with fries. Both entrees were very yummy. We both ate every late bite of our lunches. Service was good but not so attentive. Bathrooms were clean.

So…. 4 stars because dinner was 5 stars but next day lunch was 3 stars at best! Nantucket suffers from seasonal works who never quite buy into the full “mantra” of what the owners are trying to present. Dinner was amazing, hostess and host (bro with busted elbow) were so nice and took us to the whiskey lounge. Had amazing Philly cheese steak rolls and sushi. Serice was great Next day lunch was just not good. Good yes, service and treatment, yikes!!! Many employees are just moving at a pace of “whatever” Asked for balsamic glaze for my heirlooms. After asking, I watched the waitress clean 2 tables, take another order and then bring it when I was done. This is not hard, just lazy and not truly up to speed on hospitality. Pic shown! The place is soooo cool and lots of history. Will I go back?

Coming up to Nantucket for a wedding and a post Halloween windstorm delayed our ferry quite substantially giving us a choice: Walk into the wedding ceremony 20 minutes late looking like a pair of southern drifters or grab a bite and a beer at Brotherhood of Thieves. We made the right choice! Walking into this 1700s whaling bar felt made us feel like we were headed in for a celebratory boozing binge after taking down Moby Dick 🐳 The food and ambiance were awesome but Brooke really made this place shine, she was phenomenal. We will be back!!!

Brotherhood of Thieves in Nantucket is a fantastic spot that perfectly blends cozy charm with delicious cuisine! I ordered the **chicken kebab Mediterranean plate**, and it was absolutely divine. The chicken was perfectly grilled, juicy, and bursting with flavor, complemented by a vibrant array of fresh veggies and a side of flavorful tzatziki. The atmosphere is inviting, with a laid-back vibe that makes you feel right at home. The service was friendly and attentive, enhancing the whole experience. If you’re looking for a great meal in Nantucket, Brotherhood of Thieves is a must-visit! Five stars!