Brooklyn Pizza

My husband and father in law are both from Brooklyn, New York and they say that this is by far the best Ohio-based pizza that resembles New York. We go here for special occassions, other wise we would eat it every day 😌. Our favorites are Bianca (white) slices, Calzones and the Cannolis! Delicious!

Got these two slices for 6.75 out the door! The cheese pizza is spectacular! Service and atmosphere are nothing to write home about, but they make some darn good pizza here! If I’m in this area again it’ll be my go to for sure.

Pizza was amazing. Native New Yorker who came with us said it was pretty damn good but "suffered from thin crust". As a local here I've always preferred thin crust! Only real complaint is that the TV was absurdly loud even after they turned it down.

My wife is a huge New York style pizza fan. Picked this up via carry out, got cheese, pepperoni and some cannolis. Pizza was phenomenal and the cannolis were huge and by far the best I’ve had. I’m not the pickiest pizza lover, it was good. I also love all the other styles as well, but those cannolis…. Those cannolis are what dreams are made of. Cannot recommend a better pizza place for central Ohio.

Brooklyn Pizza is a solid choice if you’re in the Powell area and craving great pizza. It’s primarily a takeout spot, but they do have a few tables inside if you want to dine in. The atmosphere has a cool, authentic vibe, with New York memorabilia covering the walls that gives it real character.