Broken Plate Kitchen

On October 10, 2025 we hosted a rehearsal dinner for 80 people at this restaurant. There are no words to describe the amazing service from Amaloi Crossman and her wonderful staff. Everyone was so professional, accommodating and friendly to our guests. The bar staff was perfect and the chef cooked each meal to perfection, and every meal was hot when delivered. Knowing how important this event was to us, Amaloi decorated the venue to match the bride’s wedding colors and it was gorgeous! All of our guests commented on how wonderful the evening was. If you are looking for amazing food while in Corolla or hosting a special event that you know will be done the way you want it to be, look no further than the Broken Plate. My deepest thanks to Amaloi and staff 💗

We made reservations for a party of 8 at 5:00 and were seated immediately. The server was friendly and took good care of us. The food was great. We ordered the Blackened Snapper, Jerk Salmon, and Scallop appetizer (all pictured) and kids pasta (not pictured). Everyone loved their meal. The snapper was very well portioned and moist on the inside. The salmon was moist and had a good jerk flavor and the glaze was sweet smokey and spicy. They were able to do 2 checks for our party, and the family we were with ordered the shrimp and grits and a Caesar salad with Chicken (along with some other kids meals). Overall we liked this place and would come back during out next trip to the OBX. One thing that did strike me as odd however, is they charge a 3% credit card processing fee. I didn’t kn

The food was delicious and they were getting busy pretty quickly even in an off season. Very near and clean. Our server was wonderful, very attentive, and overall service was very good, other than a minor issue with a couple of ingredients missing off my spouse's sandwich, but it was addressed and taken care of immediately. Best she-crab soup I've had, and my fish and chips entree was perfection, though not in a typical presentation. The batter was so good. Chicken tenders were delicious too!

We absolutely loved our experience at The Broken Plate! Kevin provided an excellent service experience. The drinks were on point. We had the espresso martini and the rum punch. The she crab soup of the day was delicious 😋 The fish and chips was cooked really well. The scallops were perfection! The dark chocolate mousse cake was devine. Everything from atmosphere to service to food was exceptional. We will absolutely be back!

Breakfast was delicious and there were some great options for vegetarians that weren't your typical (boring) breakfast fare. We had the Tacos, Market Hash and Chocolate Chip Pancakes - all were awesome. It's located on the second floor above an arcade and there was no wait when we got there mid morning. Service was good as well. The place had a Jamaican flair. Would go here again!