Borrelli's Pastry Shop

We were given a recommendation to stop at this little gem and boy, I’m glad we stopped! It was a pastry shop heaven! I’ll start off by saying, there’s something here for everyone. Trust me on this. Check out the pics if you don’t believe me. Cookies, cakes, muffins, calzones, breads! You name it. Oh and the smells. Yeah, you’ll wanna buy something from here. $35 later! Eve was also super sweet and she gave us some of her own recommendations as well.

We have used Borrelli's for everything from birthday's, Halloween treats, weddings, even gender reveals. We have loved them for decades! Never a disappointment. Prices are reasonable and the food is so good it's worth every penny. It's the go to bakery for everything!

We had ordered our wedding cake from here for our wedding back on 10/11 and it was absolutely perfect!!!! It looked exactly as expected and tasted even better and our guests RAVED about it!!! The entire process was so smooth too and was delivered right on time - special shout-out to Ashley for helping us plan out our order over the past few months!!!! Would highly recommend!!!

The staff are very nice. However my fiance ordered a birthday cake for her mother's birthday and it was supposed to be a nice light whip frosting instead the cake was covered in fondant way way too sweet. It was to the point NO one at the party enjoyed the cake sadly. Would not recommend for custom cakes, Stop and Shop and Dave's have better cakes. The individual slices of cheesecake were very good though!

I genuinely don’t understand the hype around this place. The pastries look nice behind the glass, but that’s where the appeal ends. The cannoli shells were stale and rubbery, and the filling tasted like straight sugar with zero depth or authenticity. The tiramisu was dry, bland, and had barely a hint of espresso ,more like a cheap grocery store knockoff than something from an Italian bakery. The prices are outrageous for the quality you’re getting. If I’m paying premium bakery prices, I expect fresh, flavorful desserts not something that tastes like it’s been sitting out for days. Customer service was just as disappointing. The staff seemed annoyed to be there and acted like basic questions were a burden. No warmth, no pride in the product, nothing that made the experience enjoyable. Ov