Big Cheese

Pizza-wise, this is up there as some of the best in Middletown. I love the thick dough and crust, that's how you make a strong and delicious pizza! Cheese is even, tasty and the perfect amount of stringiness. The sauce is flavorful and not too overbearing... perfectly complimentary. All in all, a fantastic pie! The price for the pie wasn't expensive either, much more favorable than other top-tier spots. Curly Fries are also great in taste. Very mom and pop vibes, which is great. Small interior, so you may want to consider takeout. The location isn't bad and has some parking. Will definitely visit more as one of the better spots in this area.

Ordered the shrimp scampi very delicious came with a salad and garlic bread. Very friendly staff I've been coming here since 2008. Never been sick, and the food is always good. Highly recommend if you're in town. They also deliver. Breakfast grinders are fire as well.

Always great best pizza im middletown hands down had big cheese pizza when i first moved to Middletown in 2006 tried other pizzerias non like BIG CHEESE 🫶🏻 keep up the great work guys ❤️❤️❤️

This was my 1st time ordering from here I ordered a bacon cheeseburger, regular cheeseburger, french fries, a 12inch a 16inch steak n cheese Grinder with mozzarella sticks. My kids enjoyed the burgers the steak was decent it needed to be seasoned a little more this was a neutral experience for me...

I usally order for delievery because I am disabled.they will yell me 30-40 minutes it takes well over an hour to get it and it is usally cold. Its not so much of the hour and half it takes its the fact if going to take thay long tell someone. They take your number so no reason why they cant call you and tell you its delayed. So mad right now.