Benny's Pizza

Best pizza in Dutchess County, hands down! Benny, the owner of Benny’s, has pizza-making in his blood. His family ran Gjoni’s Pizza in Yonkers, and he carried on the tradition working at the family-owned Little Jozef’s before opening Benny’s on his own. You can taste the passion and experience in every bite. The Drunk Grandma Slice is a must-try — packed with flavor and cooked to perfection. If you’re looking for authentic, top-quality pizza at a great price, Benny’s is the place to go!

If you’re looking for restaurant-quality food without the restaurant price tag, this pizzeria is a must-visit. Every dish is prepared with care, using fresh ingredients that you can truly taste. The flavors are incredible, the portions are generous, and the prices are more than reasonable. It’s rare to find a place that delivers such high-quality meals in such a welcoming, casual setting. Highly recommend!

I decided to come here after school with my youngest son for a slice of pizza. The cook was really friendly, asking if I’d been there before and welcoming us warmly. The girls were super friendly too — you can tell it’s very much a family place. Their bacon chicken ranch roll was awesome, and I’ll definitely be back!

Must must must stop in. This place is a gem. Pizza is thin, has a nice crisp to it. Garlic knots are the old school traditional ones, smothered in olive oil and garlic. Wings both buffalo & bbq were fall off the bone tender. Damn… got my mouth watering just thinking about the food. The owner Benny took great care of myself and family- treated us like his. We will be back to enjoy ourselves soon again.

Benny’s is hard to describe in the best way. The food was absolutely amazing, and the employees guided me so kindly through all the delicious options. The owner was incredibly sweet and genuinely caring—you can tell he truly values his customers and runs the business with heart. I will definitely be coming back!!!