Bennett's Sandwich Shop

People may say I’m nuts about this review, but my sandwiches weren’t good. I’ve heard great things about their steak and cheese, a sandwich I love and get at a ton of places - so I went out of my way to try it. The major issue was the rolls were not fully cooked on both $13 subs. Felt mushy, steamed and unappetizing. I put them in the oven to make them edible. The steak and veggies were tasty, but due to issues I couldn’t say it was great (even if in a cooked bun). Just okay. I gave them a generous 4 and will try them again. It could have just been an isolated issue. The service was good and quick. It also looked like they had a very coordinated staff and clean kitchen.

5 stars across the board. The girl that served us was very personable and the food came out so quick! The atmosphere.. ? Absolutely love it, so homey, relaxed and adorable. Then the sub's..? Absolutely delicious, my husband got a tblt & I got the Italian mix and it wash l was perfect, not too much and not too little meat, not too much bread on the rolls either. Absolutely will be coming back!

On vacation and stopped by for a lobster roll which was very good. My husband got the lobster grilled cheese. It had a lot of lobster meat but was served on grilled white bread. It would have not only looked more appealing but the taste of the sandwich would have been much better on a heartier bread such as sourdough.

I enjoyed Bennett’s Sandwich shop. They have an extensive variety of sandwiches- I went for the falafel sandwich (small) and my partner shared a large Italian Spicy sandwich with his friend. The sizes are very large- even the small was more than enough. I thought the flavors of the falafel sandwich were okay, but I thought the bread was a little undercooked. It was soft but not very flavorful. I think a slightly tougher/well cooked roll would have elevated the taste a bit. They have a large variety of alcoholic and non alcoholic beverages, wheelchair access and a single gender neutral restroom.

Outstanding! Stopped in for a Steak and Cheese and it was great. We shared it with our family and my 2 year old had the sweetest reaction, she said "Delicious" with a chef's kiss. Quick and awesome service. The fountain soda was perfect. Do yourself a favor and eat here.