Benito's Slice House

Came here for lunch. Found them on Google maps and decided to try it out. So glad I did! Very delicious. The restaurant is super clean and inviting. Order at the counter and they bring it to you when it's ready. I had the combo including 1 pepperoni slice and salad w/soda. Unlimited refills on soda and tea. The salad was the freshest salad I've probably even bought at a restaurant. Pizza was heavenly and crust was divine. Price was affordable. Two thumbs up 👍👍!

Ordered 2 pizzas on app, one gluten free only to find out when I showed up to pick pizza up, they had no gluten free crust, so I asked would you not accept order if you didn't have ingredients and let your customer know so they might order something else? Was asked by Paul was it a preference or true allergy, not sure what difference that made. Was then told by "Paul" with some attitude that he just got there. Paul does not seem like he needs to be in customer service or maybe was having a bad day, regardless asked about a refund on the $19 gluten free pizza and was told it would be refunded. Ordered wings instead and asked if he could bring them across the street, he was reluctant, I asked if I needed 2 come pick them up, he said no. When he came to drop them off, he did not acknowle

Used to come here when it was 1860 pizza co. and really miss it, but decided to give the new place a try. Had wings, a side salad, and a few slices of pizza. Overall the pizza was really missing something, the sauce was a little sweet and the mozzarella tasted pre-grated and bagged. The wings were overcooked and quite dry and the side salad was literally just lettuce and tomato. The place is clean, the staff are super friendly, but the food is missing for me a bit. I will give it another chance because it is close to home and I won’t go to major pizza chains, but I left disappointed that our new pizza place wasn’t what I was hoping for.

My husband and I tried Benitos today for the first time. We had the mozzarella sticks and a meat lovers pizza. Everything was excellent. I don't normally order mozzarella sticks because they aren't good (too cold) when they get to the table. These were amazing right down to the last one. The pizza was really good, the crust was cooked perfectly, they didn't skimp on toppings and the sauce was not sweet, it had a slight sweetness from the tomato it's made from but not that yucky sweetness like Domino's sauce. We will be back loved it. Nick was great!

The pizza was absolutely delicious! Perfect crisp and thickness and not greasy. I ordered the 2 slice combo and it was so good I had to go back and get 2 more slices! Absolutely recommend this spot if you’re craving some good pizza!