Benedetti's Supper Club

We had our first time at this old-school supper club, and it was a great experience. The menu offered a wide variety of dishes, including a soup and salad bar, and the prices were reasonable. We opted for the ahi tuna and lobster tail, along with the au gratins, which were all very delicious. The service was attentive and the bar staff was generous with their pours. Overall, we had a wonderful time and would definitely recommend making reservations.

We had a reservation for 12 and the night started off really well--they graciously accommodated by adding a table for two more people. Sometimes large groups are hard to handle, but waitress Grace was a genius and even split the many checks without error! Classic prime rib, cooked to order steaks, well-made Wisco-style old fashioned and manhattans. All 14 people enjoyed their meals. It is under new ownership (Jayme) for about a year, but she has kept it just the same. Excellent hospitality, and--of course--you've got to try the ice cream drinks!

Our whole Saturday night experience was wonderful! Great drinks at the bar from Nate, and our server Trish was friendly and answered all our questions about the menu. The salad bar was well stocked and clean, and the chicken gnocchi soup was amazing! We all ordered steaks and I added on a lobster tail. Everything was delicious. Steaks were prepared as ordered, well seasoned, and the lobster tail was done to perfection. All the staff was attentive and friendly and the new owner stopped by our table to check on us. It's been a while since I've been here, but excited to add it to my regular night out rotation, food and and service have definitely been elevated since the previous ownership.

Good news first. Our service was excellent. We love a good supper club. A couple things that I want to mention. The Haystack onion ring appetizer was most certainly not thin rings Haystack style which is our favorite so when we see them we order them. They were fat rings and unfortunately cold, burnt and actually a very small order. Also, my wine pour was not even two fingers. Everything else was very good.

Finally got a chance to grab a meal here and boy, it did not disappoint. From the cocktails to the appetizers, the entrees to the desserts... everything was spot on. Best meal I've had in half a decade. The service in both the bar and restaurant (Thanks Grace!) was impeccable; friendly and attentive. It's not the least expensive restaurant ever but it's worth every penny. 10/10 will come back!