Bayshore Bagel & Coffee Co.

We bought some bagels here and thought they were really premium and good! The bagels themselves are about $2 each, but totally worth it because they're huge / thick! These were probably one of the best bagels that I've had in my life! Definitely recommend this place!

Small local walk in shop. They made one of the best caramel Cold Brew Lattes I’ve had. The pastries all look very good, along with the coffee cake I bought. The bagels are also fresh, and the sandwiches are huge! 100% worth the price and hope they continue to keep it that way. Thanks, looking forward to visiting again soon.

The early bird catches the best bagels in Cape May!!! Got them fresh and hot right out of the oven at their adorable shop in the Villas. The bagels are large, full of flavor and absolutely delicious!!! Will definitely be a repeat customer!

I was so happy when I stumbled upon this place! The homemade big puffy bagels are fantastic. The Asiago is my favorite! Try it with the Bacon scallion cream cheese. You won't regret it! They have a delicious selection of other baked goods. Stuff like Homemade pop tarts, cinnamon rolls, and brownies I often can't resist adding to my order. Don't miss the Station 60 breakfast sandwich either. It's no joke! You need a nap afterwards! There are a few small tables outside but it is generally a take out only place.

The food was good. I got an un-toasted plain bagel with butter. The bagel was a little chewy but overall good.