Bay Water Bagels — Online Orders Only

We ordered the mini bagels for my son's birthday party and they were a big hit! We had so many people ask where we got them from. The bagels were fresh and the cream cheese was delicious. Gabrielle was a great communicator throughout the entire process of ordering them and having them delivered, she was such a pleasure to work with! I highly recommend ordering from Bay Water Bagels and plan to use them when we want bagels in the future!

In a city full of bland chain restaurants, Bay Water Bagels is a fantastic exception! Fresh, homemade bagels, far superior to anything else you can get in town. Made by someone who clearly has a passion for what she is doing! Online ordering was dead simple, prices were fair, and pickup was smooth. Bagels were hot, fresh, and delicious. I also ordered the chocolate babka which was equally delicious, and possibly better than the babka I had when in NYC! Order for your family, or your workplace, you won't regret it!

I am literally obsessed with these bagels!!! I'll never forget my first bite - I had gotten a castlevetrano bagel with garlic cream cheese from Bay Water Bagels at the farmers market downtown in acacia park this summer and I have not been able to stop thinking about it ever since! I've been fortunate to have tried a selection of bagels and cream cheeses ever since, as I'd madly rush to the farmers market every chance I could get to try another variety. Recently, we hosted a breakfast party and it was the perfect opportunity to order a ton of different flavors from the website. I felt like a kid in a candy shop! (Except I am just a former New Yorker in a bagel shop!) We ordered a bunch of minis as well as some larger specialty bagels, plus several different whipped cream cheeses. I was wo

These bagels are fantastic! The best I've ever tasted. The cream cheese is also fresh and made from scratch. Everyone must try these bagels!

These bagels are AMAZING! They hit all the right notes—crispy on the outside, chewy and soft on the inside, with a bold yet perfectly balanced flavor that’s not overpowering. The texture is spot-on: dense but soft inside, with a crisp, even crust. The toppings stick without making a mess. They’re excellent fresh (and toast up beautifully) and make a quick, delicious treat straight from the freezer. We tried Cheddar, Parmesan, Flaky Sea Salt, and Blueberry in our first order, and I've already ordered more flavors (plus a few repeats). These bagels are a must-try!