Bay Brothers Seafood

The BEST seafood we've had! The deveined shrimp and crab cakes were amazing, super fresh and deliciously seasoned, cooked as we waited! We had to eat it right there on the bench in front of the place 😄 Impressed with the corn and potatoes, hubby went back in to get more! Staff was very friendly, and the whole place is so clean! If we lived closer, we'd eat here every week.

I was impressed. Finding food in a small town can be challenging and I am so glad that we stumbled into this place. Walking in, I was impressed how clean everything was. Super friendly staff offered to make us all kinds of things so don’t be fooled by their small menu online. The crab cakes were some of the best I’ve had traveling up and down the East Coast. I would definitely recommend this place to any out of towners looking for a top notch seafood market that cooks on site. Next time I go I’m definitely getting some of the bacon wrapped scallops!!

We got all our Christmas fish here. Excellent service. Reasonable prices. Fresh!!!!

Incredible value for the freshest food! Great service as well. We had the steamed shrimp + scallops and the crab cakes meal and it was all perfectly cooked (to order).

The absolute best quality fresh sea food around! They have bulk options too which is perfect for a clam bake, BBQ or large party gathering. They have everything from bacon wrapped scallops, so many types of fish(cut in differnt ways), and Alaskan crab legs to shrimp. I stopped in a few times after being told about them. I was impressed with the customer service and exceptionally friendly staff. They have bait for fishing too! (Thank you to the young man at the counter and in back wokring on 7/1/2024 around 1:30 for the story about the blue fish! )