Batter Up Bakery

We used Batter Up Bakery for our wedding cake on 8/2/25 and we had a great experience! We worked with Candice who was very helpful. We went for a tasting in February and were able to try different cakes, fillings and frostings. We eventually settled on a chocolate cake with oreo mousse and white buttercream frosting. We gave them inspiration pictures of the design we wanted and the bakery did exactly what we wanted. Batter Up was by far the most reasonably priced bakery we spoke with as we planned our wedding. They also give you a gift certificate to come back for a 1 year anniversary cake. Our cake was delicious and all of our guests really enjoyed it! Thank you for a delicious wedding cake!

This is hands down the best bakery I’ve been to on Long Island. Their vanilla cake is addicting and so are their rainbow cookies and everything else on the menu. Pics attached of the cake and cookies they made for my son’s 1st birthday. They were spot on with the pictures I showed them, prices were reasonable, and everything was delicious. We will be coming back!!

We had such an amazing experience with Batter Up Bakery for our daughter’s Quinceañera cake. From the initial consultation call, to the cake tasting, and the day of the event they went above and beyond. They provided us with excellent customer service making sure we were satisfied every step of the way. We ordered 2 cakes for the party; 1 for back up and let me just say… they were absolutely phenomenal!! From the presentation to the delicious taste! The tres leches cake was probably the best I’ve ever had. A lot of my guest definitely asked where we got the cake from. I would definitely recommend Batter Up Bakery for anyone with cake/ pastry needs!

This review goes to anyone that has not yet tried Batter Up Bakery, Don’t walk RUN to Batter Up Bakery!! We were celebrating my son’s 9th Birthday and ordered a specialized RoBlox cake look at the detail!! My son and my family ate it up!! We also ordered special St Joseph pastries with his special Chantilly cream!!! We also got black on black (black and white) cookies for me they are the absolute best cookie, no one can touch it!!! Like I said at the top of this post don’t walk RUN to this special hidden gem located in Levittown! They will make every effort to make sure that all of your sweetest dreams come true! Thanks Batter Up family! We will be back soon!!!!! 🎂🍪💙❤️

We used Batter Up for our wedding cake and they were great to work with. Very organized and responsive. We chose dulce de leche and nutella fillings which were delicious. We love how the cake came out and we also received a 1 year anniversary cake which was beautiful.