Batavia's Original Pizzeria

Let me preface this by saying, I dont usually write reviews unless my experience was really good or really bad. This one is more to bring attention to the cooks / owners. So ive had wings here before, very tasty. My service experience has always been prompt and courteous. But last night I decided to actually order a pizza. Just a simple cheese with cup and char pepperoni. Im not sure if its because it was part of the family deal or what but ive had better pizza from a Lunchables. Overly thick, not crispy, tasteless dough that tasted like it was premade dough from tops, cooked in my oven at home. Clumpy chewy cheese and the lamest cup and char pepperoni. Im not sure if it was just an off night or what but I was not at all impressed. Being from the buffalo area I have definitely had my fair

Batavia’s Original is a must try when you’re in town. The building was the home of the original Pontillos established in 1947. The food and service were both great!

I am not thrilled by Batavias original everytime we go unfortunately. I keep trying, but after our last experience we wont be back. 1st bad experience we had, our waitress never brought us silverware, even after being asked. 2nd time, I went with a friend, total we had 3 kids who did personal pizzas. It took over 45 minutes just for the kids to get there dough , sauce etc to even make the pizza. This last time we went, we waiting 10+ minutes to place a drink order, people were going up to the soda machine and refilling there own drinks. My kids did make your own pizzas, the sauce: worst sauce Ive ever tasted, tasted like tomato juice. Also took forever. My husband and I ordered chicken fingers, plain, with medium sauce on the side. We were brought out bbq chicken fingers. not what we order

I had my bridal shower here on the patio and it was absolutely perfect!! Mary grace was super helpful and easy to work with while planning. They allowed us to come in early to set up and were extremely attentive during the entire shower!! Food was absolutely delicious and everything went perfectly 😀

Stopped in for lunch today after an appointment in town. Ordered a personal hot honey pizza, a Buffalo chicken calzone, and a half order of hot buffalo wings. The wings were nice and crispy, the pizza crust was crisp and delicious, and they use fresh basil and mozzarella! Everything was delicious and was served quickly. Our server was friendly and attentive. The place was clean and inviting. I would definitely stop back again when in town.