Baldinos Giant Jersey Subs

I was really excited to eat here after seeing a TikTok review. Unfortunately, my first experience didn't live up to the hype. I expected a line (7p), but I doubt expect to wait 30 minutes for our food (one cold and and one hot Philly)! There were only two employees and the manager was taking orders and on the grill. Prior to us ordering he announced that they only had one pan of bread left in the whole restaurant. The whole place? Unfortunately, the bread seemed old. It was dark brown, thin and tough. Almost as if it was baked before rising or over proofed. After finally getting our food (I think the grille guy forgot about out order)only after I got up and stood at the counter did he realize we still hadn't gotten our order. I realized it was a problem because we were ticket 80 and they

I’m honestly blown away by how good this place is. Baldino’s has been around for over 50 years, and you can taste that experience in every single bite. This is my new go-to sub shop, and it puts the big chain places — especially Subway — to absolute shame. The quality of the meat is on another level: fresh, flavorful, and sliced thick so every bite is satisfying. The bread is soft yet sturdy, and the portions are HUGE. These aren’t skimpy sandwiches — they’re fully loaded and built right. What really makes Baldino’s stand out is the value. It’s hard to find high-quality ingredients at affordable prices nowadays, but they deliver both. Their daily specials starting at $5.99 are unbeatable, especially considering how massive the subs are. The staff is friendly, the service is fast, and the

Delicious fresh food! Great service with kindness and a smile. My mom and I were definitely impressed. We are born and raised in NJ so we know a great sandwich. We highly reccomend this establishment for a great authentic taste of home. The cookies are amazing as well. Worth the drive every time. We come from Buford.

So disappointed. I stopped by the Baldinos in Doraville for the first time and left shaking my head. I drove from Stone Mountain, waited in a long line, and expected a great Italian sub. The one I got had barely any meat on it. Once I opened it up, it looked more like a veggie sub with a little meat sprinkled in. I guess you have to ask and pay extra just to get a normal portion, which shouldn’t be the case. On top of that, my husband’s Philly cheesesteak was another miss. We paid for extra meat and still ended up with a flat, bland sandwich. No seasoning, no flavor, nothing that said “Philly” except the name. For the hype and the drive, this just wasn’t worth it.

Place looks like an old diner, staff look slow, but get your order ready quickly, cookies are good not too sweet & sandwich bread is really good & fresh. I liked the tuna sandwich & stir fried was okay, make sure when you order your food that you tell them which toppings you want. Don’t be fooled by the pictures, the food tasted good enough after 1 hour later thanks to good old Friday traffic.