Baileys Harbor Cornerstone Pub

Stopped into Cornerstone Pub thinking I’d just grab a quick bite… next thing I know I’m three drinks deep, debating whether I should move to Baileys Harbor and become a regular. First off, the fish fry deserves some kind of Wisconsin medal. Perfectly crispy, big portions, and paired with fries that mysteriously disappear faster than they arrive. I’m not saying I ate too much, but I did briefly consider unbuttoning my pants like it was Thanksgiving. The cheese curds were top tier — nice and squeaky like all proper Wisconsin curds should be. If your curds don’t squeak, are you even in Wisconsin? The place has that classic Door County pub vibe: friendly people, cold drinks, Packers stuff everywhere, and the kind of atmosphere where strangers will talk to you like they’ve known you since ki

We loved the Baileys Harbor Cornerstone Pub! They have delicious seafood chowder, hamburgers, French fries, and onion rings. Everything we ordered was great! Their staff were friendly and helpful. We also loved the view of Baileys Harbor from the tables by the windows! ❤️

We stopped specifically for a fish fry at 6pm on a snowy Friday in winter. There was plenty of seating available when we arrived. The waitress got to us quickly. She upsold us to a Cherry Brandy Old Fashioned -- very wise on her part. We split an order of Whitefish and an order of Haddock. Lots of skin on the Whitefish. Haddock was done amazingly. I got a side of German Potato Salad. It was not the vinegar flavor one would expect, but much more sweet and made with red potatoes. My wife thought it was very good, and she doesn't like German potato salad!

Good food in a friendly atmosphere. Prices are fair and they have a good selection of beers and cocktails. Decent amount of parking and seating. Burgers are always juicy and flavorful. We go here almost every time we come to Door County.

Great Friday fish fry with lots of choices. Also an outstanding salad option. Our server Tanya took great care of our party and made suggestions for fish and side dishes. The brandy old fashioneds are outstanding. Don’t miss the cheese curds and Big Pretzel appetizers.