Bagelicious Cafe

Overrated. But it’s the only bagel place in town. Prices are grossly high. Quality is mid. The tables are covered in crumbs and seeds from previous eaters. 2x they’ve gotten my order wrong and I didn’t realize it until I got home. Wish there was someplace better. A bagel w/ cream cheese and a Gatorade. $8.29. Nearly $10!? The rainbow bagels used to cost $1 more than regular bagels for some reason. Now they’re $1.50 more. That’s a 50% increase for what? Greed.

Bagelicious in Thornwood is more than just a bagel shop--it's a true neighborhood gem and the definition of a five-star experience. As soon as you walk in, you're greeted by the staff, who are incredibly friendly and efficient. The bagels themselves are consistent and delicious. My personal favorites are the Everything Bagel, generously coated on both sides, and their Bacon, Egg, and Cheese sandwich. The owners truly care about the quality of their food and their community. The service is quick considering the long lines I see sometimes and the food is consistently great. If you live in or are just passing through the Thornwood area, do yourself a huge favor and stop at Bagelicious. You'll never go anywhere else for your bagel fix! Highly, highly recommended!

These bagels are amazing and fresh . The sandwiches are stacked and so delicious, and the cream cheese taste super fresh with great flavor choices. Coffee is strong and smooth, perfect for a warm everything bagel. The staff is very pleasant and friendly, which makes the whole visit feel easy and welcoming. What sets the spot apart is the care and the little things- precise toasting, well packed orders, Hot fresh bagels made throughout the day , nothing is frozen and that welcoming, family run energy you don’t get everywhere. Easily the best Bagel experience around. I highly recommend, come to Bagelicious Cafe .

This bagel spot is the real deal. They Make the bagels fresh all throughout day, so every bagel comes out warm, soft, and perfect no matter what time you stop in. The shop is spotless, which I really appreciate, and the staff is extremely friendly and upbeat. Service is quick, orders are packed right, and the whole experience just feels cared for. Easily my go-to for a fresh, legit bagel every time.

The food is great! They have the best fresh bagels! There are so many varieties of bagels and cream cheeses. Everything is delicious. The service is quick, and the workers are very nice and pleasant. You are treated like family !