Bagel Supreme | Wallington

I go to this place often. I keep giving them a chance. Depending on who is working definitely has an effect on how your bagel will be. If it’s the man that I believe to be the owner your food will be amazing. If it’s not him sometimes I don’t stop in. Today I made the mistake of stopping in when he wasn’t working. Anyhow I order an egg bagel with EXTRA butter. I got a hard bagel with minimal butter. I feel bad but it’s just been to many times. I’ll drive to the bagel place in heights.

Tried ordering the morning after my birthday celebration, Called and asked to add a small black coffee to my order. The first girl was super sweet and going to add it and suddenly some man got on the phone aggressively, asking for my card information and REPEATING IT OUT LOUDin front of whoever was there several times, Then saying it declined (When I know very well that it definitely Has money available and even offered to repeat it Once again-Knowing that this man would literally scream it out in front of anybody) My coffee maker literally broke yesterday, so I’m waiting on my replacement and it’s crazy to think that people can be so rude knowing other peoples circumstances. I highly suggest the bagel supreme and Rutherford over Wallington. (Which is the one I meant to order from and didn

Place is unsanitary. Workers not wearing gloves while handling foods. Found piece of what looks like Saran Wrap in bagel. Do not recommend.

Used to come here often and I recommended this place to my mom She wanted an egg sandwich on a roll and a hashbrown. They ended up putting the hashbrown inside the sandwich which could be an understandable miscommunication but they responded by saying it will cost extra to have it separated Not so pleasant to hear

Thought I'd give these guys another shot. Received stale croissants a few times and a muffin with mold growing on it. They lost my business after today. Asked if the croissants are fresh and the guy behind the counter told me they are "soft". Oh and another muffin with mold on it that my two year old was going to nibble on. Stay away. Quality check isn't great and the bagels are decent at best. Photos of the muffin attached.