Atlantic Pizzeria & Restaurant

A taste of Italy right here in Freeport, Zio Rocco the Owner cooks up some.of the most authentic Italian food. I know I've been eating it all my life. From his pizzas to his pastas, whatever you like he has, and if he doesnt have it he will easily make something per your request. And it may be the funkiest pizzeria you'll ever go to because Rocco seems to love Jazz, jazz is the theme. He has memorabilia and a giant flat screen playing jazz performances all day. So catch a slice and some Miles Davis and your good, your better than good your Money ..buona fortuna

The food is absolutely incredible. The portions are big, and the flavor is fantastic. The owner is so personable and friendly. He engages with every customer and makes them feel welcome and important. They redecorated the seating area about a year ago, and the space is absolutely beautiful. We go here often and only have great things to say about it.

I thought I knew what good buffalo pizza was, but then I tried Atlantic Pizzeria's Buffalo Chicken slice... easily the best slice of pizza I have ever tasted. Perfectly crisp with nice chunks of spicy buffalo chicken. I also just had to try a grandma slice since I watched the 5 customers before me order them and I am so grateful that I did. The grandma slice was sooo flavorful. You can tell the sauce is homemade. I will definitely be back!

By far, the best pizzeria on Long Island! As soon as I walked in, I was greeted as if i was family which that is something you don’t see much these days. I ordered a regular slice for a quick lunch and it was easily the best slice of pizza I have ever had. That being said, I came back after work to try something else for dinner. The Chicken Parm Hero was amazing. The semolina bread is the best I have ever had. The sauce was perfect. The amount of chicken and cheese is well portioned. I also tried some of their stuffed garlic knots which I saw almost every single other customer ordering and I see why! Perfect little cheesey bites to have with any meal. I will definitely be back every time I’m in the area. If I could give this place 10 stars, I would. Definitely a Happy customer here!

Had a regular and Sicilian, Sicilian was ok but way overcooked for my taste , regular was literally the WORST, most greasy slice of pizza I've ever been served anywhere ever! Paid $4.50 to throw it in the trash can! Should be ashamed to serve a greasy floppy, literally soggy with grease slice to a customer and charge for it...