Athenian Greek Taverna
Commack, NY · Greek restaurant
- Address
- Athenian Greek Taverna, 2188 Jericho Tpke, Commack, NY 11725
- Phone
- (631) 499-7660
- Website
- www.atheniangreektaverna.com
- Status
- Closed · Opens 11:30 AM
Athenian Greek Taverna is a restaurant located in Commack, NY. It is one of 106 restaurants listed in Commack. Its 4.1-star rating is slightly below the Commack city average of 4.3 stars. There are 10 photos associated with this location.
About Athenian Greek Taverna
Long Island's Greek Foodie TavernaAuthentic Greek food you don't have to buy plane tickets for. Yiayia's recipes and a whole lot of love.
Hours
| Saturday | 11 AM–9 PM |
Customer Reviews
Delicious food with fresh ingredients and authentic flavors. Everything was well-prepared, and the service was warm and welcoming. Would definitely visit again & highly recommend.
This is by far the best Greek place I’ve went too. Our waitress Abby was great, attentive and friendly. We had the 7 layer dip..a must have, so much flavor never had hummus that good and spicy feta. I got the falafel which tastes home made not frozen or preheated. The lemon potatoes were also good. The lamb gyro was tasty and filling. We definitely couldn’t finish everything. We also had Manuel clear our tables with his friendly personality. Definitely going there again great experience and food was def a 10.
Well.... Where to start. Let me just say the service was fine. Very pleasant and helpful but unfortunately that is all that was good. I spent $30 and it was the biggest waste of money for takeout I have spent. I ordered something called the jack of all Gyros, and let me tell you it wasn't even a duece.for starters they top it with some type of cheese but it was burnt so bad that I couldn't even tell you it's cheese. Next there was supposed to be a siracha infuse tsaziki sauce and there was no sauce on it or on the side, it was as dry as my grandfathers scalp. The soup that I got with it was chicken orzo was so salty I had one spoon of it and it burned my tongue.The only decent thing that came with it was the green beans and had to use the juice to put on the main dish just to soften it up.
❌ Extremely disappointing experience. This place falsely advertises itself as a “taverna,” but in reality it’s just a regular, casual restaurant — no music, no ambiance, nothing remotely festive. We ordered a shrimp dish priced at $30 and received only 4 small shrimp. Not jumbo, not a large portion, just 4 tiny pieces on a plate. Since they constantly bother us to bring the main course we had to take it to go. Thats why realized the portion later on. We were expecting a tavern to have our mezes, music and fun by taking our time. When we questioned the bill (which didn’t match the menu prices), the server said that was the “cash price” — no such disclaimer was made clear before. Staff was uninterested and rolling eyes all the time. The entire experience felt like a tourist trap. Avoid at
The gyro platter was really good. Both the lamb and the rice were delicious. Nice friendly service too
Accessibility & Amenities
Services
Top Restaurants in Commack
| Name | Rating | Reviews |
|---|---|---|
| Mac Tax CPA | ★★★★★ 5.0 | 20 reviews |
| Redefine Meals | ★★★★★ 5.0 | 20 reviews |
| Won KBBQ | ★★★★★ 5.0 | 20 reviews |
| Chicos Tex Mex Commack | ★★★★★ 4.9 | 20 reviews |
| Shah’s Halal Commack | ★★★★★ 4.8 | 20 reviews |
| SAFFIRE | ★★★★★ 4.8 | 20 reviews |
| Frankie's Table | ★★★★★ 4.8 | 20 reviews |
| Kurofune Japanese Restaurant | ★★★★★ 4.8 | 20 reviews |
| Mihana Japanese Bistro & Bar | ★★★★★ 4.8 | 20 reviews |
| Cold Stone Creamery | ★★★★★ 4.7 | 20 reviews |
This listing is informational. Contact the business directly to verify credentials, services, and availability.