Artisan Ice Cream

This is located right at the centre of Paia. We arrived just before closing time. We ordered the dutch chocolate, mango strawberry guava with li hing mui and lilikoi butter scoops. The ice cream was so rich, creamy and delicious. My wife remarked mango strawberry guava as the best ice cream she has ever had. The flavors were unique and very accurate. We would love to come back here.

As a vegan traveler and a husband requiring gluten-free options, it’s often a struggle to find rich, creamy vegan ice cream options that aren’t just sorbets. Artisan Ice Cream in Pa’ia was a game-changer for us ! I was thrilled with their vegan Double Chocolate with Cocoa Nibs — it was indulgent, with a deep chocolate flavour and the perfect crunch from the nibs. My husband enjoyed the Coconut Coffee flavor, which had the ideal balance of coconut’s creaminess with a coffee kick. The young lady who served us was so welcoming and helpful, making our experience even better. I’ve heard that other ice cream spots may have better tasting traditional ice cream, as for vegan options, Artisan matched our expectations. Highly recommend it to anyone looking for delicious vegan treat!

One of the locals recommended us this ice cream place, so my friend and I decided to check it out. They have dairy and vegan ice cream options, and you can try different flavors before deciding. The only negative that I can think of is that they have limited flavors compared to some other ice cream shops on the block. I got 2 scoops - one scoop of tahitian vanilla and 1 scoop of peppermint chip. My friend tried their vegan coconut macadamia ice cream option. Each scoop of ice cream was pretty big. You can pick between different cup sizes and cones. The texture of the ice cream was really smooth. It was creamy and sweet. The mint flavor in peppermint chip wasn't overpowering, which I was happy with. There isn't any seating area inside the ice cream shop. It's only meant for carry out. The s

The best ice cream I’ve had on the island and maybe ever. My wife would agree as well! Small batch, made in-house and very unique flavors that will appeal to everyone. Mia was so sweet to us and our daughter. Her service made me feel like she truly cared about our experience and for that, we will be back before we leave the island!

My typical order over 4 1/2 weeks of blissful Maui living... Sea Salted Peanut Butter Chocolate Chip ice cream, and the puffiest peanut butter chocolate chip cookie in the case... sweet and salty perfection... heavenly!! Delicious small batch ice cream in lovely flavors, the cutest little storefront that makes you feel like you've found a secret door, and the friendliest crew welcoming us in each time. We LOVED introducing friends and family to this gem! Wish you were located in Minnesota, but probably good that you're not. 🤣 Thank you for making us feel like locals! ❤️