Arcaro and Genell, Old Forge, PA

Finally tried old forge style pizza and they did not disappoint. Got classic 12 cut red pie. We felt salt was missing just a touch but they had grated parm and red flakes which sealed the deal. Crust is crunchy but airy in the most sublime way. Atmosphere is of that of a mom and pop shop but they have been open for years. A bit political leaning but that is understandable considering it's a small town. Overall we had a great experience and ate in peace. It was monday afternoon when we dropped by. Their dine in was closed but take out was open and had stools.

A group of us stopped by to try Old Forge pizza before we left town since we heard so many good things, so we stopped by. Even though they weren't really open for dine in and were just doing takeout, they graciously told us to come on in and served us even though they were short staffed. The food absolutely lives up to the hype, and I can't say enough great things about how delicious the pizza was. But more than that, the staff were so amazing and friendly, and in a totally genuine way. Please do yourself a favor and check this place out! Thank you again for being so welcoming.

I flew from CA and my family drove from CT just for the pizza. I used to frequent Arcaro and Genell's when I lived in Scranton, so I wanted to taste that wonderful pizza again. The staff was so nice and super friendly. We purchased five boxes so that we could take some home!

I ordered boneless wings here to take to work for my break, they came floating in oil so I couldn't taste the sauce it just separated the sauce and was inedible, I'm very surprised such a popular place would serve such a thing other than that the place looks amazing and the cashier was very pleasent

Had to travel to Wilkes Barre, well worth the extra time to go to Old Forge. The classic red pizza tray was delicious, whole family loved it. Crust was perfect slightly crispy on bottom and great bread texture. The tomato and onion flavors are well balanced. The white pizza is also good, tons of cheese. Goes great with tomato soup the next day. Only slight issue was woody rosemary leaves on the white pizza, other seasonings are tasty. The kids enjoyed a quick game of bocce ball while the adults picked up the pizzas. Staff were friendly. Didn't get dessert this time but they're always delicious too